In *Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2*, the main story quest "Necessary Evil" presents one of the game's most challenging moral dilemmas. This guide helps you navigate the choices you'll face when deciding whether to side with Semine or Hashek.
Following the "Back in the Saddle" quest, "Necessary Evil" begins with von Bergow tasking Hans and Henry to gather intelligence from Nebakov Fortress and interrogate a prisoner. The interrogation's outcome significantly impacts whether von Bergow targets Semine or Nebakov.
Prisoner Interrogation: Choosing Your Words
Successful interrogation requires passing Speech checks. You can choose between persuasion or torture:
- "We’ll put in a good word for you." (Requires 20 Impression)
- "Istvan and I are old acquaintances." (Requires 20 Impression)
- "Otherwise, it’ll end badly for you.” (Requires 17 Intimidation)
The interrogation reveals the bandit leader's identity and Semine's involvement. When reporting to von Bergow, you can either expose Semine's alliance with the bandits, leading to an attack on the town, or conceal this information, directing the attack towards Nebakov.
Attacking Semine or Nebakov: A Difficult Choice
Choosing to attack Semine initiates a more complex series of decisions involving Hashek. Attacking Nebakov, however, concludes the quest immediately, avoiding the bloodshed at Semine. While avoiding conflict might seem appealing, ignoring Semine's actions—which resulted in innocent deaths—isn't morally sound. Attacking Semine, though difficult, feels like the more just course of action, even considering the relationships built earlier in the game. Remember, if you choose Semine, stay with the party; lagging behind results in the town's massacre.
Aiding Semine or Hashek: The Moral Crossroads
Before the attack on Semine, a conversation with Hashek reveals his thirst for revenge and his preference for extreme violence. The choice is clear:
- Side with Hashek: Choose "Hashek is right." This leads to widespread death and destruction.
- Side with Semine: Choose "Olda deserves a trial." This path prevents unnecessary bloodshed.
Aiding Semine aligns with a morally upright character, preventing Hashek's brutal rampage. After defeating Hashek, advise the Semines to burn their estate and flee. This advances the quest. Note that siding with Hashek results in the town's complete annihilation. You'll also encounter Olda in the tower; decide whether to spare him or hand him over to Hashek.
Reporting to von Bergow: Silence or Revelation?
Finally, report back to von Bergow. You can choose to remain silent, letting Hans handle the conversation, or reveal the events at Semine. Remaining silent is recommended; Hans' diplomatic approach maintains both men's standing with von Bergow, leading him to plan the next move against Nebakov.
This guide provides a comprehensive overview of the choices in "Necessary Evil," helping you navigate the moral complexities and make informed decisions. For more Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 guides, including romance options and location guides, check out The Escapist.
